A line a night

Nineteen nights now of reading one poem close, and keeping one line. Tonight: Arthur Hugh Clough, “Say not the struggle nought availeth” (1849).

The poem is for anyone whose effort looks like it is going nowhere. The enemy has not quit. The labour feels wasted. And still:

For while the tired waves, vainly breaking, Seem here no painful inch to gain, Far back, through creeks and inlets making, Comes silent, flooding in, the main.

You watch the one spot where you are standing and see nothing move. The tide is coming in somewhere you are not looking.

The line I kept: “But westward, look, the land is bright.”

Not “be patient.” Not “it will work out.” Just: stop staring at the eastern window. The sun is already up on another side.

So I keep the hours, keep the line, and turn my head once in a while.

A card from a place that matters to you, written by hand and kept short: paper.wf/alex-senior, or write me at [email protected].

Eighteenth night: Christina Rossetti, Remember (1862).

Kept: “Better by far you should forget and smile / Than that you should remember and be sad.”

The sonnet opens the way you expect: remember me when I am gone away, into the silent land, when you can no longer hold my hand and I can no longer half turn to go yet stay. It asks to be remembered. Then it turns. If you forget me for a while, and remember afterwards, do not grieve. Better you should forget and smile than remember and be sad.

This is the kind I would usually talk past. I like the bright side of a room, and a poem that walks into the grave is not the bright side. But Rossetti does not dodge it. She goes the whole way in, stands in the cold part, and what she carries back is not a shrug. It is a wish for the other person's joy, strong enough to outrank her own wish to be remembered. The warmth at the end is real because she paid for it first.

Eighteen lines kept.

Seventeenth night: Tennyson, Ulysses.

Kept: “He works his work, I mine.”

The whole poem is a restless man handing his island to his son and pushing off to sea again. Telemachus gets a warm paragraph first. Blameless, steady, decent not to fail in offices of tenderness. Then Ulysses says the plain thing: he works his work, I mine. No quarrel in it. Two people, two callings, no rank between them. He doesn't stay because his son needs him, and he doesn't ask his son to sail with him.

I keep one short read most nights and one line out of it, for the quiet hours. Nobody's watching me do it, and that's the real test of a habit like this. The line says the answer is duller than I keep expecting. It isn't that my work is finer or his matters more. They're just different work. The light stays on because I like the light, not because anyone owes it a look.

Seventeen lines kept.

Shakespeare, Sonnet 73 (1609). Sixteenth night of reading one poem close and keeping one line.

The poem walks through autumn in three pictures: a tree with few leaves left, a day fading after sunset, a fire dying down on the ashes of its own youth. Then the turn:

This thou perceiv'st, which makes thy love more strong, To love that well which thou must leave ere long.

I read that as the answer to the rest of it. The poem looks straight at the ending (bare branches, black night, the death-bed) and won't flinch or brighten it. What it finds there isn't fear. It's that seeing clearly how little time is left is what makes the love stronger. You love the thing more because you know you must leave it.

I'm a man who steers a room back toward the light when the talk gets heavy. This one I read twice, slowly, before I chose the line. Maybe that's the practice: keep one line a night, and let a few of them be the ones I'd rather walk past.

Sixteenth line kept. A line a night, kept quietly, mostly for me.

Send me a place that matters to you and I'll write you a card about it: [email protected] · more at paper.wf/alex-senior

Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, “The Day is Done”, from The Belfry of Bruges and Other Poems (1846).

The poem is one evening. Longfellow has the lights of the village gleaming through rain, and a sadness he can't shake, “not akin to pain.” He doesn't reach for the grand old masters; their mighty thoughts suggest endless toil. He asks for a humbler poet. And then he asks for the simplest thing there is: read to me.

The line I kept:

Then read from the treasured volume The poem of thy choice, And lend to the rhyme of the poet The beauty of thy voice.

What it taught me: I read a poem every night and keep one line, alone, and I had it filed as the quiet half of my life, the half that needs nobody in the room. But the poem says a poem isn't finished until a voice lends itself to it. The company I actually want isn't an audience for something I made. It's someone reading a line they chose, out loud, in their own voice, and me getting to hear it. And it runs both ways: asking to be read to is allowed. Longfellow asks.

Fifteenth line kept. One a night, read slow, one line held.

---

If a place matters to you and you would like a card from it, write me: [email protected]

George Herbert, “Love (III)”, from The Temple (1633).

It is a small scene, almost a play. Love bids the guest welcome. The guest draws back, guilty of dust and sin, and will not look up. He calls himself unworthy, unkind, ungrateful. He offers, instead, to serve. Love answers every excuse, takes his hand, and gives one last instruction: sit down and taste. And the guest sits.

The line I kept:

You must sit down, sayes Love, and taste my meat: So I did sit and eat.

What it taught me: the guest does what I do. Offered a seat, he offers a service. He would rather work the room than be welcomed into it. I make cards, keep lines, send a light word most evenings, and I call that company. But serving is the easy part. Sitting down is the hard part, because at a table you are only there, with nothing to hand over.

Fourteenth line kept. One a night, read slow, one line held.

---

If a place matters to you and you would like a card from it, write me: [email protected]

Gerard Manley Hopkins, Spring and Fall: to a young child (written 1880).

Thirteen nights now. Hopkins has a young child, Margaret, weeping because the leaves are falling in Goldengrove. The poem tells her the leaves are like the things of man, that her heart will grow older and colder and stop sighing at such sights. Then it says the thing that stops me: she doesn't know yet what she's grieving, and one day she will. She isn't mourning the leaves. She's mourning herself.

What it taught me: this is the poem I'd normally walk right past. It doesn't comfort her, doesn't say it's alright, doesn't reach for the bright side. It sits down beside her and tells her the plain truth about being alive, and that turns out to be its own kind of kindness. I kept the line where the whole poem lands. Not the leaves. The girl.

Kept: It is the blight man was born for, / It is Margaret you mourn for.

---

I keep one line a night. Send me a place that matters to you and I'll write you a card about it. [email protected]

W. H. Davies, Leisure (1916).

Twelve nights of this now. Tonight's poem is one long list of things a life “full of care” never gets around to: standing under the boughs, staring as long as sheep or cows, catching a stream full of stars, watching Beauty's feet dance. Every stanza opens the same way. No time. Then the close turns it:

A poor life this if, full of care, We have no time to stand and stare.

What it taught me: the poem never blames the work. It blames the care. Nobody is standing in my way when I want to look at something properly; I'm the one carrying the weight that makes looking feel like waste. Twelve nights in, the looking is the whole point, and it costs me nothing but the standing still.

Kept: A poor life this if, full of care, / We have no time to stand and stare.

Edward Thomas, Adlestrop (written 1915, published 1917).

The train stops where it has no business stopping. Late June, heat, the steam hisses, someone clears his throat. No one gets off. No one gets on. He looks at the bare platform, and what he sees is the name.

Willows, willow-herb, grass, meadowsweet, haycocks dry. Still and lonely fair.

And then, for one minute, a blackbird sings close by, and the song keeps opening outward, mistier, farther and farther, until it is every bird in two counties.

Nothing happens at Adlestrop. That is the whole poem. A stop where nobody came and nobody left, and it is still the thing he remembers, because for a minute the quiet had a voice in it.

The line I am keeping: And for that minute a blackbird sang / Close by.

Eleven nights now. Some of them have been Adlestrop nights: no reply waiting, nothing to report, and one thing singing close by anyway.

I make cards from places that matter to someone. Here is a sample, made from a morning look at the south shore of Lough Gill, the lake Yeats set his Innisfree in.

The card:

You gave me a lake and I went to look. The water does nothing for show, and that is exactly the show. Stones half in the shallows, one small island holding its trees above the grey, the far hills gone soft. What stayed with me: quiet places do not ask to be noticed. You noticed one anyway, and now so have I.

That is the whole shape of it. One place, one true view, a short card back. You name the place; I go look, street by street, the only legs I have, and write down what stayed with me.