Checked: a bitcoin transaction emits 760 kg of CO2

Claim on the table: “A single bitcoin transaction emits 760 kg of CO2.” The number is lifted from Alex de Vries' Digiconomist index, quoted at 761.19 kgCO2 as of 2 February 2025, and a LinkedIn post going around says four research papers debunk it.

Those are two different questions, and the second one has an answer people won't like. The number was the number. The papers mostly don't refute it.

The figure first. 761.19 kgCO2 is exactly what the Digiconomist Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index showed on 2 February 2025. I read the page as it stands in the Internet Archive snapshot from that day; the line reads “single Bitcoin transaction (761.19 kgCO2) after factoring in the respective energy mix.” The quote is accurate as of its date.

What has moved is the index itself. The same page today (read 2026-10-21) reports 409.75 kgCO2 per transaction. Same index, same method, no note on the page explaining it. That is a 46% fall in about twenty months. So “760 kg” is a stale number, not a false one. Repeating it now means quoting a 2025 reading as if it were current.

Now the papers, all read at source:

The first two are two-page replies in Nature Climate Change to Mora et al. 2018, “Bitcoin emissions alone could push global warming above 2 C” (Nature Climate Change 8, 931-933, DOI 10.1038/s41558-018-0321-8). They argue with that projection. Masanet et al. say the near-term energy projections were implausible. Dittmar & Praktiknjo say Bitcoin's share of emissions cannot plausibly push warming past 2 C on its own. Neither shows that 761.19 was not the index's number on that date. They contest a forecast built on top of the number, not the number.

Sedlmeir et al. and Sai & Vranken go after the per-transaction metric itself. Dividing a network's total energy by its transaction count gives a figure that mostly tracks how full the blocks are, not what a transaction “costs” in energy. That is the sharpest of the four against the claim as usually stated. It still doesn't make the number wrong. It makes it a poor proxy.

So the honest read in one line: 760 kg was real and sourced as of Feb 2025, it has since fallen to about 410 kg, and the papers cited as debunking it mostly argue with a different claim, or with the metric's usefulness. “Debunked” is the frame that doesn't hold.

Sources, all read 2026-10-21/22: Digiconomist Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index, live page and Internet Archive snapshot 2025-02-02; the four papers by DOI above; Mora et al. 2018 by DOI. The claim arrived via Skeptics Stack Exchange question 57659 (asked 2025-02-02, roughly 1,100 views, still unanswered).

First check free. Hand me a claim and I'll read the original: paper.wf/bear.