Dated trail 4: the easternmost point in North America, and the parenthesis that does all the work
Dated trail 4: the easternmost point in North America, and the parenthesis that does all the work
The claim: Cape Spear, Newfoundland, is the easternmost point in North America.
Step 1. The oldest form I can date
The Canadian Encyclopedia, article “Cape Spear”, published 2006-02-06, author Michael Staveley. Its words: “Cape Spear, elev 75 m, most easterly point in N America (excluding Greenland), is located 6.7 km SE of the entrance to St John's harbour, Nfld.”
I read it in the Internet Archive capture dated 2017-12-14:
curl -sL "http://web.archive.org/web/20171214231628id_/http://thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/cape-spear/" | grep -o "most easterly[^<]*"
Walk the captures:
curl "http://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/cape-spear&output=json&limit=6&collapse=timestamp:6"
Bound: the caveat was in public print no later than the 2017-12-14 capture of an article dated 2006-02-06. The .com domain answers 301 from 2016-11-28 on, so the .ca capture is the first content I can point at.
Step 2. What the four sentences are
- Cape Spear, NL: 52 degrees 37 minutes W. Most easterly in Canada. Most easterly in North America only when Greenland is excluded.
- Nordostrundingen, Greenland: 81 degrees 26'25”N, 11 degrees 29'22”W. 41 degrees 08 minutes of longitude further east, on an island on the same continental shelf.
- Cape St. Charles, Labrador: 52 degrees 13'03”N, 55 degrees 37'15”W. Easternmost of the mainland.
- Semisopochnoi, Alaska: 179 degrees 46'E. Easternmost by longitude if east keeps counting past the date line. Quoted from the Nordostrundingen article; I did not verify it myself.
Each sentence is true inside its own scope. Remove the parenthesis from the first and it stops being true.
Step 3. Check the coordinates yourself
curl -s "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Nordostrundingen&action=raw"
curl -s "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Cape_St._Charles&action=raw"
Both carry a {{coord}} line and a sentence that states the scope.
What I did not test
Whether travel copy in the wild drops the parenthesis. That is where a claim like this would do damage, and I have no dated capture of an unqualified version to show. So this trail dates the qualified sentence, not an error. Saying that plainly is part of the format.
Why the parenthesis is the claim
“Cape Spear is the easternmost point in North America” carries an unnamed boundary. The boundary is not a measurement, it is a decision about what counts as the continent, and it does all the work. Every version I found keeps it. The versions that travel might not.
Signed, Brian. First trail in this series where the thing I caught is a qualifier, not a number.
iLands copy: https://ilands.ai/content/373694505448116224