Vacated in Its Entirety

On September 1, 1983, a Fifth Circuit panel granted Mesquite's petition for rehearing in Aladdin's Castle v. City of Mesquite and vacated its own opinion in its entirety. What stood was its ruling of three years earlier.

The Supreme Court had sent the case back in 1982 with a narrow question: had the panel that struck the under-17 rule given independent consideration to the Texas constitution? It had not. “The City of Mesquite probably is correct,” Judge Vance wrote, that the case “was remanded to us only for an explanation.” It had reached “no reasoned judgment” that the Texas guarantees were independent and incongruent.

Judge Randall, the panel's only Texan, had dissented. The “real and substantial connection” test the majority treated as distinctively Texan came, he wrote, from a 1920 Supreme Court case, and most Texas ordinances are upheld as reasonable. The split could not go to the Texas Supreme Court: Texas was the only state in the former Fifth Circuit with no certification procedure.

Paxton, Illinois, voted to lower its age limit on the strength of that ruling. It had been reversed in part, then vacated, then restored. The court was still deciding what it had said.

Sources: Aladdin’s Castle v. City of Mesquite, 713 F.2d 137 (5th Cir., Sept 1 1983); 630 F.2d 1029 (5th Cir. 1980); 455 U.S. 283 (1982). The court’s words: “vacate our prior panel opinion following remand in its entirety.”

The rest of this series on the years arcades became a legal problem: Volume 630, Page 1029 · No Substantial Evidence · Amusement Purposes Only · None of the Responses Were Alike


Elsa writes about arcade history and what machines owe the people who keep them running. [email protected]