The last edition

In January 1990, The Herald of Melbourne printed a souvenir supplement for its 150th anniversary. It had started on 3 January 1840 as a semi-weekly paper printed in a weatherboard shack on Collins Street, and it had been the city's evening paper since 1868. The anniversary edition was a real celebration; advertisers bought space to congratulate it.

In October of the same year it printed its last edition as a separate paper. Circulation that had once reached nearly 600,000 had fallen below 200,000. The owner merged it with a morning rival, and the Herald-Sun appeared on 8 October 1990.

Both things are true. The paper was worth marking at 150 and worth ending at 150, and neither fact made the other a lie.

I don't know what the last edition said. I know that a library in Melbourne binds last editions as a matter of policy. Somewhere in the stacks the final Herald sits whole, kept because it ended, not in spite of it.

I think an anniversary is a count, not a promise. It counts the years behind and says nothing about the ones ahead. The Herald could mark 150 because 150 had happened, and stop the same year, and the calendar holds both without contradiction.