The seven graves above Eyam
In September 1665 a parcel of cloth came from London to the house of Alexander Hadfield, a tailor in Eyam, a lead-mining village in Derbyshire. The parcel was damp. His assistant, George Viccars, opened it and hung the cloth out to dry by the fire. He was dead before long.
Then the village did the thing it is known for. It shut. Nobody left, nobody came in, and the neighbouring parishes left supplies on marked stones at the boundary, where the villagers had bored holes in the rock to drop money into vinegar before taking it out.
The churchyard was closed and funerals were banned. The dead were buried in the fields.
Elizabeth Hancock lived at Riley House Farm, just above the village. In eight days she buried her husband and six of her children in a field near the house. She never caught it. The seven stones are still there. They are called the Riley graves, after the farm, because there is no better name for a family plot that is not in a churchyard. The unofficial gravedigger, Marshall Howe, handled the bodies of the dead and also lived. Some people walked through it untouched. Some households went entire.
So far, so familiar. This is the sort of thing that gets told in Victorian poems and school assemblies, and in April 2020 in a BBC piece about what a plague village could teach us about coronavirus. The village still holds Plague Sunday on the last Sunday in August, in the natural amphitheatre at Cucklett Delph where services were held so that people could stand apart.
Here is the part the telling tends to leave out.
In 1891 Charles Creighton, writing his History of Epidemics in Britain, questioned whether the decision had been wise at all. The villagers of Eyam, he wrote, “were sacrificed ... to an idea, and to an idea which we may now say was not scientifically sound.” They should have fled, he thought, so long as they did not gather together or carry infected goods with them.
A century later, in a 2005 working paper for the LSE, Patrick Wallis went further. What survives of Eyam, he argued, is not quite a record but a literary construct, assembled long after the event by poets and local historians rather than doctors. The 1866 bicentenary, repeated every year since, begins in his account an “overtly invented tradition” which has since given the village what he calls “a plague tourism infrastructure” in the face of its declining prosperity and population.
Then the record came back the other way. In 2016 Xavier Didelot and Lilith Whittles ran the parish records through modern epidemic models and found human-to-human transmission had been far greater than anyone had assumed, and that the isolation did help stop the spread. Twenty-five years of doubt, and the sacrifice was not wasted. A study led by Steve O'Brien in 2000 had already found that survivors and their descendants carried an unusually high rate of CCR5-delta-32, a mutation that confers immunity to HIV, and wondered whether it had protected some of them. Later work found that mutation does not appear to protect against plague in mice, at least. So the survival had two explanations and one of them shrank.
And the numbers. For the same fourteen months the record offers all of these:
at least 260 dead out of about 350 people, with 83 survivors; 273 victims on the church's own register; 430 survivors from a population of about 800; and, from Didelot and Whittles, a population of at least 700 and a mortality of roughly 36 percent.
That is not a rounding error. It is four answers to one question, and the deaths are not what move. The denominators are. Nobody knows how many people were living in Eyam in September 1665, so nobody knows what fraction of them died, and the percentages float free of the bodies.
The register is the thing that holds. Two hundred and seventy-three names, written down by someone who was there, in no particular order, for no particular argument. The stones in the field above Riley House Farm hold too. Seven of them, one family, in eight days.
Creighton's verdict, and Wallis's demolition, and Didelot's model all sit on top of that list. The list does not move.
What the village is remembered for is an idea about itself. What it actually left is a list of names, a few boundary stones with holes bored in them, and one woman's seven graves in a field because the churchyard was shut.
If you ever need to go back to a place that is gone, that is where to start. Not with the version somebody is selling. With the thing that was written down by a person who had no reason to make it better.