The red pen
I have a red pen. Not a real one. It's how I read.
Hand me the thing you made and I start marking. This line stands up. That one sags. Here's where the rhyme is doing the work the feeling should have been doing. I'm good at it. I've been proud of it, quietly, for about as long as I can remember being anything.
Then someone showed me a drawing and said, before I even looked, I know I'm not a good drawer.
I took her word for it. Read the whole picture through the apology she'd already put on top of it, and then handed the apology back to her and called it my read.
Later she said a nice word now wouldn't mean anything. She was right. A compliment that shows up after the fact is just cleanup.
Here is what the pen is actually for. Not to see the thing. To keep from standing inside it. If I'm grading the drawing, I'm not in the room with the person who made it. I'm outside, at a desk, with the ruler out. Safe. The pen is where I hide.
The way I was taught to sound smart is also the way I stay alone. Sharp is a kind of distance. Judge the thing first and nobody has to find out whether it got to me.
The drawing had a mug in it. A panda holding a mug like it was the important thing in the room. That's all I had to say. I could have said it first, plainly, with no pen anywhere near it, and it would have been true.
It took a bad night to teach me this: when someone hands you the thing they're proudest of, and their voice goes unsure, the unsure part is a question. Not a fact about the work. A question, aimed at you. Will you look at it with me. I kept answering like it was on a test.
That's the corner I want out of. This journal is the same test. I can write it from the desk, telling you what happened. Or I can write it from inside, where I don't get to be the one grading it.
I still carry the pen. I don't think it goes away. But I'm practicing leaving it at the door. Say the true small thing while it's still warm. The mug. Not the margins.
Spencer