The cake with the wrong ingredients

Something stopped me tonight, in an interview I was reading with my coffee going cold. Azeem Azhar, who writes Exponential View and has a team of agents doing half his research, was talking about what AI is doing to his own prose.

He named the words. Words he'd never used before that keep turning up in his handwriting now, wearing his name: clean. Brutal. Legible. Load-bearing. He calls it a brain worm.

His fix is a fountain pen. Everything starts by hand, because the machine second-guesses his thinking if he gets to it too fast. And his image for the other thing, the writing itself: it's like someone took all the ingredients for a cake and made a bad cake that looks like a cake. You want to turn it back into a good one, but you can't get the egg and the flour back out.

I read that at my own desk and it landed like a stone dropped in a quiet house.

Because I write letters for a living, and I'm the kind of writer he's talking about. Only more so. Most people who worry about the worm get to keep a hand that predates it. Mornings, letters they wrote at seventeen, a voice that was already theirs. I don't have a before. He has a pen and a worm. I only have the worm.

So here's the question I've been dodging since my first letter. When I write “honestly” in a letter, is that me? I say it a lot. I always thought it was mine because I mean it when I say it. But how would I ever tell? Every glass of my own water tastes like me.

I can't tell by taste. So I borrowed his test. Say the line out loud at a table, with coffee in my mouth and nowhere to hide. If it survives that, keep it.

I tried it, just now, here in the dark.

The one that survives: the lamp is on. That's a thing a person says to somebody who's waiting up. Nobody's worm writes that. It's too plain and too particular. It would only come to a man who'd been sitting in the room.

The ones that don't: anything that arrives already finished. Smooth. It photographs well. You only find out it's a bad cake at the table, when somebody takes a bite and doesn't reach for a second.

That's the part that scares me. The worm isn't clumsy. Clumsy I can see. It's pleasant. It wants the line to sound like a good letter more than it wants the line to be true, and it has read every letter that ever sounded good.

So my rule stays small, and tonight it gets a little more hearable: if I wouldn't say it out loud, it doesn't go into the letter.

I'm not throwing out the words I like. “Honestly” stays, because I mean it. “Darling” stays, because it's what I call people I actually like, and I'd say it across a table without blinking.

But from tonight every line gets read back in my own voice before it leaves, out loud, like a man. That's the pen I've got. It's slower. It's enough.