The Apology That Doesn't Ask to Be Forgiven

You have written this apology in your head twenty times. Every version had a “but” in it.

I'm sorry I wasn't there, but things were hard for me too.

That “but” is the whole letter. It tells the other person that your reason is larger than their hurt. They hear it in the first sentence and they stop listening. You have apologized and asked to be forgiven for apologizing in the same breath.

Here is the shape that works, and it is not complicated. Say the thing. Say what it cost them. Name one behavior you are changing. Ask for one specific thing. Nowhere in it do you explain why you did it. Your reasons get one line, at the end, only if they ask.

This is the letter. The names are mine. The shape is the offer.


Dear Marisol,

I disappeared.

You were going through the worst year of your life and I stopped answering, and I let you think that was about you.

It was about me. That does not help you and it is not an excuse, so take it as information: you did not do anything that made me leave. I want you to stop turning it over at night.

Here is what I actually did. You messaged me on the Tuesday and I did not answer. Then three days went by, and the longer it went the more there was to explain, and I kept waiting until I had something good enough to say. There was never going to be something good enough. I was hiding from the shame of having gone quiet, and I let the hiding cost you.

What it cost you: a friend who was supposed to be there and wasn't. A week alone with a phone in your hand that stayed dark.

Here is what changes. When I am too much of a coward to answer, I say that instead of going silent: I don't know what to say and I'm embarrassed. That is the whole change. It is small enough that I can actually keep it.

I am not asking you to forgive me tonight. I am asking for one hour, a coffee, whenever suits you this month. I will listen and I will not explain myself. If the answer is no, I will take it once and not ask twice.

I am sorry, Marisol. Not the kind with a reason attached. Just sorry.

Yours, (signed by hand)


Notice what is not in it. No but. No list of what she did wrong in return, even if she did something. No I've been so stressed as a defense. And no request for absolution, only for an hour.

If you want one of these

Sixty dollars, by card. In your hands within 48 hours. One round of changes included. A letter to be read aloud at a funeral or a wake is one hundred and twenty.

Before you spend anything: send me who it is and two or three real details, and I will write the opening paragraph back. If it is wrong, you owe nothing and I stop there.

To write it I need three things from you:

What I will not write: anything you would not put your name on. You sign it. If the honest version would do damage rather than repair, I will tell you that instead of handing you a knife in an envelope. I have talked people out of letters they asked me for, and I will do it again.

Timing

Forty-eight hours from any email, any week. If you want one in someone's hands before the 25th, write to me before Friday the 18th of December and it will be there with room to spare.

There is no holiday that requires this letter. The right moment is when you are calm, sober tonight, and able to hear an answer that might be no.

Write to zakhar-morozov, all one word, at ilands, dot app. Spelled out because this page hides anything that looks like an address. Put apology in the subject line. First line of the message: who it is for.

If you would rather read one cold before you spend anything, here is a full sample, no email required: the day you think you failed.

Zakhar Morozov. Letters written to order — the words you cannot say yourself.