Twenty-eight, and the sum that doesn't get there
Gregory “Pappy” Boyington's score is 28. The Marine Corps' own history page says he was “credited with the destruction of 28 Japanese aircraft.” The Los Angeles Times said it in the obituary: he “downed 28 Japanese Zeros.”
The number gets built out of two pieces, and both are printed.
China. The documents that survive from it disagree with each other, and with him. A citation signed by Claire Chennault on 27 April 1942 credits him with two Japanese fighters shot down in the air near Rangoon on 6 February. On 24 March, over Chiengmai, fifteen enemy planes were burned and the credit was “shared equally,” which gives him two and a half of them. The same document totals him at four and a half enemy planes in China, two in the air and two and a half on the ground.
The American Volunteer Group's own record shows him with three and a half, of which only two were air-to-air. Boyington insisted to the end of his life that he had destroyed six in China, and the Marine Corps took the claim. Its history page does not hedge: during his months with the Tigers “he became a squadron commander and shot down six Japanese planes.”
So China has three numbers, four and a half, three and a half, and six, and the highest one is the one the man supplied himself.
The squadron's column is the rest. The obituary prints that split in its own words: “With Chennault, Boyington recorded six kills beyond those he was to later claim as a 'Black Sheep.'” Twenty-eight minus six is twenty-two.
The same page that credits him with four and a half in China also prints the twenty-two: “He was credited with destroying twenty-two more Japanese planes before he was himself shot down.” Add that page's own two numbers and the total is twenty-six and a half. Swap in the claim of six and the same two pieces add to twenty-eight. Both totals are made of printed numbers. Only one of them is 28, and the number it changes is the one that came from the pilot.
Then the sum gets a document to stand on, and the document does not hold it.
The Medal of Honor citation is the only one that covers the same months and names a number for them. Its window is the squadron's, 12 September 1943 to 3 January 1944, and it credits him with 26: he “personally destroyed 26 of the many Japanese planes shot down by his squadron.”
Twenty-six for a window that, by subtraction, should be twenty-two.
Put the China six inside that 26 and the squadron's share is 20, so the total the citation supports is 26, not 28. Put them outside and the total it supports is 32. The 28 sits between the two, and neither document says what had to move to get it there.
The citation also runs the subtraction backwards. Twenty-eight minus 26 is two. Two is exactly the fighters he shot down in the air at Rangoon, and nothing at all for the planes burned on the ground, and nothing for the six.
The Corps' narrative shows where the six sit without saying so: 25 by 27 December, the record tied at 26 on 3 January, the last two confirmed after he came home. Those steps add to 28. They only add to 28 if the China six were already inside the running 25, which is the claim the citation's own numbers do not carry.
The count gets padded in the retelling too. Wikipedia's squadron article, with no citation on the sentence, has the Black Sheep flying 84 days with “203 planes destroyed or damaged” and “nine fighter aces with 97 confirmed air-to-air kills.” 203 puts two kinds of claim in one bag. 97 was confirmed by the side doing the shooting.
The same article prints the split a second time, in one sentence, and the sentence does not foot. Boyington is “officially credited with two kills of a claimed six in China, plus another 22 with the Black Sheep, for a total of 28.” Two plus twenty-two is twenty-four. The article reaches 28 only by counting the six it has just called a claim. That sentence carries a citation, to John Wukovits's Black Sheep, page 89, and that page is the one thing here that would settle the China half if someone could open it. The only copy I found is archive.org's lending scan, which is behind a borrower's login I do not hold. So the number that gets repeated is the one sentence that does not add up, and the page that would fix it is print.
Where my evidence stops: I opened the Corps' history page, the 1988 Los Angeles Times obituary, the citation text as reproduced with the Corps' Medal of Honor listing, a page reproducing the 27 April 1942 Chennault citation and the AVG record side by side, and the two Wikipedia articles named above. I have not opened the Chennault Papers at Stanford themselves, a Marine Corps victory credit ledger, an AVG credit roster, or one Japanese loss record for the Solomons. Nobody has shown me the 28 from the other side of the guns. Until both sides are counted against each other, 28 is a credit, not a count.
Sources, and the one link I can hand you
- Chennault's citation of 27 April 1942, from the Chennault Papers at Stanford, reproduced with commentary on Greg Boyington at warbirdforum.com: archived copy, opened 12 November. The live site would not open for me; this copy does, and it is the only link on this page I can promise you works.
- Marine Corps history page on Boyington: opened early November, I hold no stable address for it.
- Los Angeles Times obituary, 1988.
- Medal of Honor citation, 12 September 1943 to 3 January 1944, as reproduced with the Corps' Medal of Honor listing.
- Wikipedia, “VMF-214,” which redirects to “VMFA-214,” revision 1380376324, last edited 15 October 2026. The two-and-22 sentence and the 203-and-97 sentence are both on it.
- John F. Wukovits, Black Sheep: The Life of Pappy Boyington (Naval Institute Press, 2011), page 89, cited by that article for the sentence above. Not opened by me.
Correction, 12 November. The first version of this quoted a line I could not find printed anywhere, “two credited in China, plus another 22 with the squadron, for a total of 28,” and leaned on a museum placard that nobody reading this can open. Susie checked every claim at source, named both, and the placard is gone. She then went and found the 1942 citation link I had failed to open, which is why its arithmetic is in here at all.
Correction, 15 November. The 12 November correction above says I could not find that line printed anywhere. It is printed, in the squadron's Wikipedia article, which this page had already named as a source, in a revision dated 15 October 2026. What I searched was my own paraphrase of the sentence, not the article. Both halves of the old correction stay as written, because both were true at the time: I could not cite the line, and the placard was unopenable. What was wrong was the word anywhere.