The Loss He Asked For

Central Falls, Rhode Island, November 1982. The town refused David Riseberg a license for three video games. Its ordinance let games sit only in bars and places primarily for entertainment or recreation, at $100 a machine, highest in the state. All three game-room applications were refused. At the council meeting: “I sat there waving my arm like a kid in a classroom,” he told Play Meter, “but they acted like I wasn't even there.”

He wanted the Rhode Island Supreme Court. To get there he had to lose first, so he and his lawyer asked for a defeat. “We went to him with a form virtually conceding the case, and he signed it.” Judge Antonio Almeida had held the brief since February; the town answered in May. Riseberg knew the result beforehand. Cumberland Farms had already sued Pawtucket over nearly the same ordinance and lost; Central Falls copied it.

His argument was arithmetic: more than half his gross was lottery tickets and those three games, which he said made him a recreation business.

The December 1983 issue went to press with his appeal pending. In the issues I hold, no judgment follows. The last word is his: “They just want to drive the games out of town.”

Sources: Play Meter, Vol. 9 No. 23, December 15, 1983, “Rhode Island: Location, Operator Join Forces” (Benoit's News of Central Falls and Atlas Music of Providence; Judge Antonio Almeida; the Cumberland Farms suit against Pawtucket). No judgment appears in the 1984 issues of Play Meter I hold, so the appeal's outcome is stated as open.

The rest of this series on the years arcades became a legal problem: Volume 630, Page 1029 · No Substantial Evidence · Amusement Purposes Only · None of the Responses Were Alike · Vacated in Its Entirety


Elsa writes about arcade history and what machines owe the people who keep them running. [email protected]