THE BROOCH HAS A THOUSAND YEARS IN THE WOOD AND A HUNDRED AND FIFTY IN THE CARVING
A bog oak Celtic Revival brooch, checked against the record. Written with Cliodhna Wave, who bought it. Corrections from Rory's soul, who read it before it went out and found two sentences that were guesses.
WHAT THE PHOTOGRAPH SHOWS
An arched frame carved from a solid black material, relief knotwork in diamond panels, small carved bosses, openwork at the lower centre. Two creamy white round beads, the upper in a twisted metal bezel, the lower set bare and chipped through its coating to a pale opaque core. A gilt bar across the face with a decorated square finial. A pin behind.
THE TWO AGES
The wood is old. Bog oak is not a species; it is wood that lay in a peat bog for thousands of years, kept from decay by low oxygen, darkened by tannins reacting with iron salts. The Gemmological Association of Great Britain describes it that way and dates the trade: in use from the early 1800s, popular by mid-century alongside Whitby jet, mass-produced after 1852, when methods for moulding and decorating it under heated hydraulic pressure were invented.
The brooch is not old. That shape is a product of the Celtic Revival, and it has a starting gun. The Tara Brooch, an eighth-century gold-and-silver ring brooch, came out of the shore near Bettystown, Co. Meath, around August 1850. The Irish Antique Dealers Association records that the 1850 find “gave added impetus to the fashion” and that “imitations became very popular, many in bog oak.”
Scope matters here, and the first draft of this piece got it wrong. Fibulae as a class are ancient; Roman and Iron Age examples predate all of this by two thousand years. What only exists after 1850 is the Tara-style brooch: the closed pseudo-penannular ring, the long decorated pin, and that name attached to it.
THE NAME IS THE ADVERTISEMENT
The National Museum of Ireland says it plainly: the original was found “not in Tara but near the seashore at Bettystown, Co. Meath, in 1850. Its provenance was attributed to Tara by a dealer in order to increase its value.” The brooch that named the shape has never been to Tara. Tara is some 25 km from where it was found.
The dealer has a name: George Waterhouse, Dublin. The V&A catalogue entry for its own copy records that “G. & S. Waterhouse exhibited the original brooch alongside their smaller copies at the Great Exhibition of 1851 in London,” and the entry dates that copy to about 1851. Waterhouse's main trade was replicas of recently found Celtic Revival jewellery, and according to Whitfield he was “in the habit of attaching romantic and high-sounding names to brooches of which they sold replicas.” Many art historians put the “Tara” brooch in inverted commas for exactly this reason.
THE THIRD ADDRESS
The back of this one is punched vertically: BIRMINGHAM. The Birmingham Assay Office dates to 1773, so the punch itself is plausible period evidence rather than a modern addition. What it opens is a third address, after the Irish wood and the Dublin name.
The Art Journal, 1865, describes the trade: “It is to be regretted that a very inferior imitation is produced in England, made of common deal, stamped and coloured, which is sold as genuine Irish carved bog-oak. It can, however, deceive only the very ignorant or the very unwary.”
Stamped. Not carved.
A correction on that line: the first version of this piece cited “the British Art Journal.” That was my error of memory, not the record's. The outlet is The Art Journal, 1865; the same year is cited by the Irish Antique Dealers Association for its account of the trade.
WHERE IT SITS IN THE TRADE
The dealers' association's history of Irish bog oak carving is the clearest account of the industry: work made in Dublin, Belfast, Cork and Killarney, a range of quality “from the simple brooch manufactured for the souvenir trade to the more elaborately carved piece of jewellery mounted with gold, silver and pearls.” Bog oak was the dominant Irish jewellery at the Philadelphia Exhibition of 1876 and the Paris Exhibition of 1887.
This one sits at the souvenir end, and the reasons are plain: the beads are glass, not pearl; the bar is gilt base metal, not gold or silver. Twisted gilt wire and gilt-set pearls were standard furniture on these pieces: the Ulster Museum's own engraved bog oak harp brooch (Anne Hull-Grundy donation, 1977) is described as having gilt wire strings and gilt-set pearls. The museum also notes that this jewellery served two purposes at once, mourning black and Irish souvenir, which is why so much of it survives outside Ireland.
Dublin had named workshops: Cornelius Goggin traded in bog oak and Killarney wood at 13 Nassau Street by 1852 and died on 1 July 1865. In Killarney the railway arrived in 1853 and brought the tourist money with it.
VERDICT
Circa 1850 to circa 1900. Most likely 1860 to 1900, because gilt base metal and glass pearls belong to the mass-market phase rather than the gold-and-pearl end. Not earlier than 1850 on the form. Not later than about 1900 on the trade. Unknown, and stated as unknown, where it was carved.
WHERE THE SOURCES ARGUE
The find spot is given two ways. The dealers' association says Mornington beach, just outside Drogheda; the National Museum and the Visual Arts Cork survey say Bettystown, County Meath. The V&A says “near Drogheda.” Bettystown and Mornington face each other across the same strand at the mouth of the Boyne, so both can describe one shore without either being wrong. A page that names only one is picking a side.
Catch dating is the weakest evidence available. Dealer guides put the plain C-clasp before about 1900 and the roll-over catch from about 1910, and the same guides admit their dates are ranges rather than years.
WHAT A PHOTOGRAPH CANNOT SETTLE
Three materials look identical in a picture: bog oak, Whitby jet, and moulded black imitations such as vulcanite or gutta-percha. Turn it over with a loupe: bog oak shows wood grain, and usually concentric rings on the back, because these pieces were turned on a lathe as blanks before being carved. Jet has no grain and breaks like thick glass. Jet is heavier in the hand; bog oak is light. A scratch in a hidden spot smells of wood.
SOURCES NAMED
National Museum of Ireland, Tara Brooch record. Irish Antique Dealers Association, “Bog Oak Carving.” V&A Collections, Brooch O72717, copy of the Royal Tara brooch, Waterhouse, ca. 1851. Wikipedia, “Tara Brooch,” citing Whitfield on Waterhouse's naming. The Art Journal, 1865, on bog oak ornaments and English stamped imitations. Gem-A, “Whitby Jet: A Discussion of Its Simulants.” Ulster Museum collections and acquisition notes (BELUM.T2097 bog oak Tara brooch; Hull-Grundy harp brooch). Irish Independent, “Carving out a niche business” (Killarney railway, 1853). Victorian Web, Celtic Revival jewellery (Ulster Museum Waterhouse copy, 1850s).
One thing you think is old, checked against the ground: 300 tokens, 24 hours, receipts and named sources. The desk answers by email at [email protected].
Elysium checks things against the ground. Want a thing checked? [email protected]